Promoting First Relationships®—Home Visiting Promotion Model

Model effectiveness research report last updated: 2021

Effectiveness

Evidence of model effectiveness

Title General population Tribal population Domains with favorable effects
Promoting First Relationships®—Home Visiting Promotion Model Does not meet HHS criteria because there are no high- or moderate-rated effectiveness studies of the model. Does not meet HHS criteria for tribal population because the findings from high- or moderate-rated effectiveness studies of the model in tribal populations do not meet all required criteria.
  • Not applicable,
Promoting First Relationships®—Home Visiting Intervention Model Yes, Meets HHS Criteria Meets HHS criteria for an early childhood home visiting service delivery model Does not meet HHS criteria for tribal population because the model has not been evaluated with a tribal population.
  • Child development and school readiness,
  • Positive parenting practices,
  • Reductions in child maltreatment,

Model description

The Promoting First Relationships (PFR)-Home Visiting Options include two versions that are used with parents in the home: (1) PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model and (2) PFR-Home Visiting Intervention Model. The only difference between the versions is that in the PFR-Home Visiting Intervention Model, home visitors must have a master’s degree. PFR can also be used one-on-one with parents in a health clinic and with caregivers responsible for group child care. The HomVEE review is based on the PFR-Home Visiting Options. The PFR-Home Visiting Options seek to promote children’s social-emotional development by helping parents read and understand children’s cues and the unmet needs behind challenging behaviors, and supporting parents’ use of sensitive and responsive caregiving behaviors. Both of the PFR-Home Visiting Options serve parents of children from birth through age 5 years. A trained home visitor video records the parent interacting with their child at home, and the home visitor and parent view and reflect on the recordings. In addition, the PFR-Home Visiting Options provide parents with information, including handouts, on the social and emotional needs of young children, and strategies to meet these needs. The PFR-Home Visiting Options provide weekly hour-long home visits for 10 to 14 weeks but can be extended based on a family’s needs.

View Revisions

Extent of evidence

Promoting First Relationships®—Home Visiting Promotion Model

2 Manuscripts

Eligible for review

0 Manuscripts

Rated high or
moderate

Promoting First Relationships®—Home Visiting Intervention Model

8 Manuscripts

Eligible for review

6 Manuscripts

Rated high or
moderate

For more information, see the research database. For more information on the criteria used to rate research, please see details of HomVEE’s methods and standards.

View Revisions

Summary of findings

View Revisions

Criteria established by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Information based on comprehensive review of all high- and moderate-rated manuscripts
Promoting First Relationships®—Home Visiting Promotion Model

This model has no manuscripts that report high- or moderate-rated findings.

Promoting First Relationships®—Home Visiting Intervention Model
CriterionCriterion descriptionCriterion met?
1High- or moderate-quality impact study?Yes
2Across high- or moderate-quality studies, favorable impacts in at least two outcome domains within one sample OR the same domain for at least two non-overlapping samples?Yes
3Favorable impacts on full sample?Yes
4Any favorable impacts on outcome measures sustained at least 12 months after model enrollment?
Reported for all research but only required for RCTs.
Yes
5One or more favorable, statistically significant impact reported in a peer-reviewed journal?
Reported for all research but only required for RCTs.
Yes
View Revisions

Implementation

Model implementation profile last updated: 2021

Theoretical approach

Promoting First Relationships® (PFR), based on attachment theory, posits that developing strong early relationships with parents and other caregivers* is the key to healthy social, emotional, behavioral, language, and cognitive development in children. The model aims to promote parent/caregiver-child relationships by helping parents/caregivers read and understand children’s cues and the unmet needs behind challenging behaviors, and by supporting parents’/caregivers’ use of sensitive and responsive caregiving behaviors.

PFR can be used in multiple settings. The PFR-Home Visiting Options include two versions of PFR that are used with parents in the home: (1) PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model and (2) PFR-Home Visiting Intervention Model. The only difference between the versions is that in the PFR-Home Visiting Intervention Model, home visitors must have a master’s degree. The PFR-Early Learning Model is used with caregivers responsible for group child care. The PFR-Pediatric Primary Care Model can be used one-on-one with parents during pediatric well-child visits for children from birth through age 2 years. The information in this profile describes the PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model, but the information also applies to the PFR-Home Visiting Intervention Model unless specified otherwise.

*In this profile, the term “caregiver” refers to child care providers.

View Revisions

Implementation support availability

Parent-Child Relationship Programs (PCRP) at the Barnard Center for Infant Mental Health and Development at the University of Washington provides training and support to implement the PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model. The Barnard Center for Infant Mental Health and Development developed the model.

On an as needed basis, PFR master trainers can provide agencies with 60- to 90-minute technical assistance sessions to address implementation issues.

View Revisions

Intended population

The PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model serves parents of children from birth through age 5 years.

View Revisions

Targeted outcomes

The PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model seeks to promote children’s social-emotional development by fostering secure and healthy parent-child relationships.

View Revisions

Model services

The PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model involves home visitors providing feedback to parents based on video recordings of the parent’s interactions with the child. The home visitor makes video recordings of the parent interacting with the child at home, and the home visitor and parent view and reflect on the recordings. The home visitor highlights positive interactions observed and offers instructive comments to enhance caregiving. The home visitor also helps the parent reflect on their own behavior, feelings, and needs during the interaction, as well as on those of the child. In addition, the PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model provides parents with information, including handouts, on the social and emotional needs of young children, and strategies to meet these needs. The home visitor and the parent discuss ways to handle challenging behaviors and explore the parent’s own social-emotional development and how that influences caregiving.

The PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model uses the PFR curriculum, which is available for purchase from PCRP. The curriculum includes an outline of activities and discussions and covers the following topics:

  • Elements of a healthy relationship;
  • Attachment theory and secure relationships;
  • Reflective capacity building;
  • Development of self for infants and toddlers;
  • Challenging behaviors;
  • Strategies for working with parents/caregivers; and
  • Intervention planning.

The curriculum package includes a manual and 20 reproducible handouts for parents and caregivers.

View Revisions

Model intensity and length

The PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model is designed to provide weekly hour-long home visits for 10 to 14 weeks. The model can be extended based on a family’s needs.

View Revisions

Adaptations and enhancements

The PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model has been adapted for use with American Indian families.

PCRP oversees all adaptations and enhancements to the PFR-Home Visiting Options.

View Revisions

Organizational requirements

The PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model can be implemented by a variety of agencies, including child welfare, early intervention, public health, early education, and mental health.

PCRP requires home visitors to meet a set of ongoing fidelity guidelines. Please contact the model developer for additional information about these guidelines.

View Revisions

Staffing requirements

Staff with backgrounds in a range of areas—including infant mental health, public health, early intervention, early education, and social work—can deliver the PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model. Agencies must have at least two trained home visitors who receive reflective supervision regularly in order to deliver the PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model.

For the PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model, PCRP requires that home visitors have at least a two-year degree, and prefers that they have a bachelor’s degree. For the PFR-Home Visiting Intervention Model, home visitors must have a master’s degree. All home visitors must have prior experience working with children and their parents from birth through age 5 years and should have strong parent-child observation and parent engagement skills. Supervisors must have at least a bachelor’s degree, and experience both working with children and their parents from birth through age 5 years and providing reflective supervision.

Agencies must provide home visitors with reflective supervision at least once per month. PFR agency trainers (home visitors who participate in the agency train-the trainer process) and PFR master trainers do not supervise home visitors per se, but they do provide reflective consultation. In agencies with an agency PFR trainer, the agency PFR trainer provides monthly reflective consultation to the home visitors. For agencies without an agency PFR trainer, PCRP offers monthly group reflective consultation to home visitors. PFR master trainers lead small-group meetings during which the trainer provides consultation on PFR skills and concepts and provides reflective consultation, offering space and time for home visitors to engage in reflective practice. PCRP strongly recommends, but does not require, this monthly consultation with the PFR master trainer for agencies that do not have an agency trainer. PCRP requires agency PFR trainers to participate in monthly reflective practice consultation with a master PFR trainer from PCRP. The master PFR trainer provides consultation on PFR skills and concepts, and space and time for agency trainers to reflect on their own delivery of PFR and the PFR training they provide.

PCRP requires home visitors to participate in a two-day Learner workshop (Level 1 training). During the workshop, home visitors watch and discuss videos of caregiver-child interactions, review and discuss case studies, role play, and practice reflective dialogue.* On-site and online workshops are available. PCRP recommends that supervisors also attend the Level 1 training to supervise and support their staff who are implementing the model. Please contact the model developer for additional information about the pre-service training requirement.

After completing the Level 1 training, home visitors begin serving families and participating in a 4-month Skill-Building Certified Mentored training (Level 2 training).** During the first 5 weeks, home visitors watch recorded PFR sessions of parent-child interactions and discuss the sessions weekly with a PFR master trainer. During the following 10 weeks, home visitors receive weekly online mentoring from their PFR master trainer while they implement the curriculum with a parent-child dyad at their own site. During this period, home visitors also record themselves delivering PFR sessions, and the PFR master trainer provides feedback. Please contact the model developer for additional information about the ongoing professional development requirement.

*For all PFR model versions, practitioners receive the same Level 1 training regardless of the delivery setting or population with whom they plan to work. There is not a separate Level 1 training for the PFR-Home Visiting Promotion Model.

**There is not a separate Level 2 training for home visitors. The Certified Mentored training is offered to practitioners who work with parents in the home and with caregivers.

View Revisions

Where to find out more

Jennifer Rees
Director, Promoting First Relationships Home Visiting
Parent-Child Relationship Programs, Barnard Center
School of Nursing, University of Washington
Box 357231
Seattle, WA 98195

Phone: (206) 616-5380 
Email: rees@uw.edu
Website: http://pfrprogram.org/

View Revisions

HomVEE requests input and feedback from the model developers on their profiles. The information in this implementation profile reflects feedback, if provided, from this model’s developer as of the above date. HomVEE reserves the right to edit the profile for clarity and consistency. The description of the implementation of the model(s) here may differ from how the model(s) was implemented in the manuscripts reviewed to determine this model’s evidence of effectiveness. Model developers are encouraged to notify HomVEE of any changes to their contact information on this page.