Home Visiting Model Effects
HomVEE has reviewed a total of 50 models. Two models that are not evidence-based (SafeCare® and Play and Learning Strategies) have versions that meet HHS criteria and are therefore also included in this table.
Displaying 1 to 52 of 52
Model | Support available for model as reviewed? | High or moderate quality impact study? | Favorable impacts on full sample? | Favorable impacts on subgroups? | Favorable impacts sustained? | Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? | Unfavorable or ambiguous impacts? | Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based? | MIECHV eligible? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No eligible studies
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No eligible studies
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No eligible studies
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? No
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? No
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Not applicable
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Not applicable
|
MIECHV eligible?
Not applicable
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No eligible studies
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? No
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? No
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? No
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Not applicable
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Not applicable
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Not applicable
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
No
|
MIECHV eligible?
No
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? Yes
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? No
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? No
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? Yes
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
|
Support available for model as reviewed? Yes
|
High or moderate quality impact study? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on full sample? Yes
|
Favorable impacts on subgroups? No
|
Favorable impacts sustained? Yes
|
Favorable impacts replicated across or within domains? Yes
|
Unfavorable or ambiguous findings? No
|
Meets HHS criteria for evidenced-based?
Yes
|
MIECHV eligible?
Yes
|
1 HHS has determined that Healthy Start is not eligible for review by HomVEE because it is a federal grant program and not a home visiting model. Information on Healthy Start has been removed from the website.
2 Entries in this row combine information for PALS Toddler/Preschooler and PALS Infant + Toddler/Preschooler.
3 HomVEE displays PALS Infant separately here so that users can more easily see results specific to PALS Infant (the only version of PALS that meets HHS criteria for an evidence-based home visiting model).
4 HomVEE displays SafeCare Augmented separately here so that users can more easily see results specific to SafeCare Augmented (the only version of SafeCare that meets HHS criteria for an evidence-based home visiting model). The main version of SafeCare itself, displayed above, has no manuscripts about a high- or moderate-quality impact studies. Some other versions of SafeCare have at least one such manuscript. Planned Activities Training (a SafeCare module) and Cellular Phone Enhanced Planned Activities Training (a SafeCare module with an add-on) show evidence of effectiveness.